Although the myth that A.A. Milne created Winnie the Pooh to reflect different mental health conditions has been debunked. It doesn’t change the fact people can see different mental health conditions in each of the characters. Thus, I thought it’d be a nice change of pace to see, “Which Winnie The Pooh Character Are You?”.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I’ll earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. Read my full disclosure here.
Let’s get the other classic Pooh characters and mental health conditions ones out of the way first. Because Pooh might surprise you.
Piglet is a pretty easy one to diagnose. I don’t think there’s any doubt that Piglet suffers from generalised anxiety. With a friend like Pooh bear and Tigger, who can blame him.
Piglet is a very timid character who always seems to be in a state of worry. Excessive worrying, even when there is no specific threat present or is disproportionate to the actual risk, is a classic sign of generalised anxiety, and a classic character trait of Piglet.
Thus, generalised anxiety pretty much sums up Piglet up in a nutshell.
Tigger is reckless, carefree, impulsive, and full of energy almost all the time. Tigger is constantly using that energy to bounce around, because after all, “Bouncing is what Tiggers do best”.
Tigger is characterised as engaging in excessive physical movement (bouncing), doesn’t like to wait, doesn’t like to sit still, and has little to no sense of danger. He also has issues with concentrating. Thus, I think it’s pretty safe to say Tigger has ADHD.
Eeyore definitely suffers from severe depression or persistent depressive disorder. Has Eeyore ever displayed any sign of being happy? He has little motivation to do anything and clearly doesn’t get joy from anything. If fact, he doesn’t seem to have any desire to do anything.
Furthermore, Eeyore is extremely withdrawn and tends to keeps to himself, and it’s only the efforts made by his friends that get him to join in with them and do something.
Eeyore is the epitome of melancholy. His pessimism and gloominess I don’t think I’ve seen portrayed in any other character this well.
However, even though Eeyore is severely depressed, he’s also not suicidal, nor does he self-harm. Thus, Eeyore’s continuous depressive state isn’t one that causes an existential crisis that would lead to him wanting to end his life. I guess that pretty much is the definition of persistent depressive disorder?
Plus, if he was suicidal and/or self-harming, that would make the adventures of Pooh and friends very different.
Owl comes across as a stuffy talkative character who is seen as a mentor type, most likely due to his age. Owl’s also presented as being one of, if not, the most intelligent animal in Hundred Acre Woods. It’s these characteristics that often lead to people believing he’s narcissistic.
Although Owl often rambles on in long speeches, using words others don’t understand, he might not be doing this due to narcissism. He also suffers from a tendency to be a bit of a scatterbrain.
The other animals in Hundred Acre Woods aren’t known for being very bright (accept Rabbit), like Pooh, who can’t read. Much like Pooh clearly has his own learning disorder, Owl to has a learning difficulty: dyslexia.
Owl has problems with spelling and can even have a hard time spelling his own name. However, Owl isn’t willing to admit to his difficulties, finding roundabout ways to hide it.
Owl, to me, is overcompensating for his dyslexia in order to hide it. What some might see as narcissistic behaviour with his long speeches, I believe is actually just his coping mechanism to hide his learning difficulty from the others. This is most likely due to the shame and embarrassment of not knowing why he has these struggles. Thus, he is driven to hide it.
This is most likely due to the fact that the others look up to him as being very intelligent. Thus, struggling with undiagnosed dyslexia could be the real cause of his narcissistic seeming behaviours and attitude. Admitting that he has problems with reading and spelling would, to him, show the others that he’s not as intelligent as the others thought.
When the other animals from Hundred Acre Woods come to him for help, due to the fact they seem him as being very intelligent, the fear of losing that must be quite a burden for him. Does he fear they’ll stop visiting him if they found out about his dyslexia? Most likely. Would they actually stop visiting though? I guess we’ll never actually know unless Disney explores that as a storyline, but I doubt they would.
Rabbit is shown to be friendly, yet irritable. He’s also a stickler for the rules, prefers things to be orderly, and likes planning. This could explain his bossy behaviour.
Because Rabbit is often bossy, as well as believing in his own intelligence and abilities, people often label Rabbit as a narcissist. However, Rabbit is capable of being nice. Narcissists can only fake that.
Thus the question is, is Rabbit’s niceness genuine? Rabbit seems to display empathy and concern for others, so I don’t believe he’s narcissistic.
Does Rabbit have delusions of grandeur instead? That doesn’t seem likely either because Rabbit, from what I can remember, doesn’t suffer from a fear of persecution which is common for people with this condition. Nor does he seem to exhibit any other form of delusions.
It seems to me that Rabbit just has a bigger than average self-esteem, but not one that really fits into a clinical diagnosis, and thus, a mental health condition.
Rabbit’s friends are rather carefree and reckless, thus if he’s the only one that wants everyone to follow the rules in order to be safe, then he may feel that this can only be done if he’s the leader. This would explain his behaviours that others see as narcissistic as being associated with his OCD instead. Which would also explain how he can also be kind and caring.
Kanga is another interesting character that I think has been harshly judged. Kanaga as a whole, is kind-hearted and patient, who is very much the mother figure who often offers motherly advice.
Kanga can be a little overprotective of Roo, which some have interpreted as being social anxiety disorder.
However, Kanga may be a little over-possessive of Roo, from our perspective, but an important part of mental health is understanding cultural norms and values when assessing for conditions.
Kanga and Roo are both kangaroos and as such, have very, very short pregnancies, 28-34 days in fact. Roo, like other joey’s, will spend 6-11 months in the pouch developing (depending on the species of kangaroo). At 6-11 months (depending on which species they are), joey’s will start to leave the pouch.
Thus, if Roo can still fit into Kanga’s pouch, and you often see him climbing in and out of Kanga’s pouch, then he can’t be that old and is still reliant on Kanga’s milk. This, for me, mean’s Kanga’s behaviour isn’t over possessive or controlling, Roo is still basically a baby. Kanga is just displaying the usual anxieties of a mother.
Kanga’s son, Roo, is a cheerful and energetically playful joey. However, some see Roo as being autistic because he doesn’t always pay attention to what’s going on around him. Other times he seems content on just being in Kanga’s pouch.
Again, seeing this as autism seems a little unfair once you consider the cultural norms and values of Kanga and Roo. Especially as Roo is actually still a baby. If anything, he’s probably more advance developmentally than he should be for his age.
Christopher Robin, for me, isn’t suffering from a mental health condition, such as schizophrenia. The stories we all grew up on show Christopher Robin as a minor, support role, who barely features in the adventures of Pooh and friends. The fact that these adventures exist without Christopher Robin being there or knowing about them, suggests to me that he’s not mentally unwell.
Pooh and friends maintain object permanence even when the supposed observer, Christopher Robin, isn’t there. Thus, Pooh and friends, in the context of their world, aren’t a delusion of some sort created by Christopher Robin’s mind, and thus they are real.
However, I’m basing this assumption based on the Pooh stories I saw as a child created by Disney. You might very well be able to claim that in the original stories released in the 1920s that Christopher Robin does meet the criteria for schizophrenia.
Instead, Christopher Robin fits the criteria of not just being a supporting character, but also a support worker. Christopher drops in from time to time and checks in on Pooh and friends, rather than joining them on all their adventures. Which is far more like a support worker would do at supported housing or a nurse type role in a hospital ward.
Pooh has been diagnosed with a number of different conditions for a number of different reasons over the years. For example, Pooh has been diagnosed with ADHD because of his scattered thoughts, chaotic and random lifestyle, and his forgetfulness. That could be a true interpretation of a lot of Pooh’s behaviours, and he is certainly a candidate for a bear suffering from comorbid mental health conditions. After all, a lot of people with mental health conditions suffer from more than one.
However, a lot of Pooh’s poorly thought out plans and behaviours might stem from his child-like mind. Pooh clearly suffers from some sort of learning impairment that means he has a lower IQ than his peers.
Pooh has also been diagnosed with OCD by some, due to his fixation on honey and counting. But could the counting be a byproduct of his low intelligence? Furthermore, if Pooh has an eating disorder like some claim, that would explain his obsession with honey. Pooh clearly loves his honey after all.
But for me, rather than calling his condition an eating disorder, I personally think he suffers from addiction. Albeit an addiction to food, or in Pooh’s case, honey. He’s only interested in eating honey, which is extremely specific for an eating disorder. Plus, Pooh’s willingness to put others at risk to get honey and how he’s consumed with thoughts of honey and obtaining honey, I feel, is more akin to an addiction, like alcohol or gambling.
For example, if you know someone with substance addiction they can have a primary substance of abuse. This primary substance of abuse is the one they can’t go without, but at the same time, they can easily use other substances of abuse in a take it or leave it kind of way. Someone addicted to heroin can take it or leave it when it comes to cannabis, alcohol, cocaine, etc. The one they can’t leave is their heroin. This is why it think Pooh should be seen as an addict, rather than a bear with an eating disorder.
At least this would have met the definition of addiction under the DSM-IV. The DSM-V is a different story. Pooh, from what I can recall, and it’s been a long time, didn’t display signs of withdrawal. But Pooh clearly had cravings for honey.
That said, I still think Pooh suffers from honey addiction rather than suffering from an eating disorder. Due to his cravings, obsession, risk-taking, and disregard for the dangers to himself and others he’s willing to take to obtain honey.
Have you ever met someone so obsessed with just one food item before?
Which Pooh Character Am I?
I think I’m closest to being Eeyore. That’s because I’ve suffered from depression almost my entire life and exist in an almost permanent state of melancholy. However, I can still experience fleeting bouts of joy, unlike Eeyore. I’ve also had issues with self-harming and suicide, unlike Eeyore.
I also have a splash of Piglet in me, because I too suffer from an anxiety disorder, just not generalised anxiety. Unlike Piglet, my worries aren’t indiscriminate, my anxiety disorders have fixed fears. I suffer from social anxiety and agoraphobia (if you’re interested in finding out more about my anxiety disorders, you can do so here, here, and here).
Although in the back of my mind I often have a more Piglet orientated anxiety, accept I can control that.
Lastly, I obviously have a dash of Owl in me too, thanks to my dyslexia. I found lots of ways to try and hide my issues with spelling and reading. Much like how Owl talk he’s way out of his secret being found out, I would write my way around the words I couldn’t spell. This would make my sentences and course work at school much longer than they needed to be as I used a series of simpler words that could have been easily replaced by one word that I knew, but couldn’t spell. It was a huge pain in the rear when doing exams.
As always, leave your feedback in the comments section below. Also, feel free to share which Winnie the Pooh character(s) you feel you are or your own take on which disorders best suits which Winnie The Pooh character in the comments section below as well. If you want to stay up-to-date with my blog, then sign up to my below. Alternatively, get push notifications of new posts by clicking the red bell icon in the bottom left corner.
Lastly, if you’d like to support my blog then you can make a donation of any size below also. Until next time,
Unwanted Life readers.
FollowFollow Unwanted Life on WordPress.com